Why I … Still Watch American Idol

This post is linked up to the Why I… carnival at Vanderbilt Wife. After reading and commenting on my post, go visit the Wife and read what others have to say!

Why I...

I have been watching American Idol religiously since the second season. I missed the Justin/Kelly drama, but I was there for Ruben v. Clay and Adam v. everyone. I groaned when Jennifer Hudson was voted off early and I applauded when Carrie Underwood went all the way. I really thought about going to the racetrack to see Lee DeWyze in his “coming home” concert. I’m a fan, and I’m proud to say it.

Most of my faithful Idol-watching friends have fallen off the Idol bandwagon. The lunchroom doesn’t vibrate with the next-day post mortem. I don’t get those emergency text messages expressing shock, amazement, or disgust about Idol performances and results. It’s all ho-hum. Or is it?

As a performing musician myself, I fully realize that there are a hundred equally good or better singers out there in the real world for every contestant on American Idol. That doesn’t take away from the outright miracle that is happening for THESE musicians. We should wish them our best and support their endeavors. They got their chance to make it big, and I don’t begrudge them a single minute on television or a single dollar they will earn. Every musician who makes a living performing live music because of his American Idol connection means that other musicians will continue to be employed, and we know that American Idol has given hundreds of musicians an opportunity that they would never have had without it. Even William Hung is still making money from American Idol.

American Idol has been charged with fixing results, and the cartoon character behavior in the judging booth over the last few seasons has diminished the credibility of the process. This season is different; the diversity of the contestants and their artistry is keeping it interesting. I have enjoyed the chemistry among Randy, Steven, and the luminous Jennifer Lopez. It’s pretty impressive when the singer with the current number one hit on the pop charts tells a performer that his or her song gave her chills. I don’t always agree with the judges, but I feel like there is balance and compassion. Ryan has grown with the franchise and is now a seasoned host who knows how to handle the talent effectively.

The first decade of American Idol has been worth watching and has been good for the music business. It seems impossible that there might be a second decade, but I’m likely to be there for that, too. It’s reality TV that is actually real; all of those contestants actually have to learn a new song every week and then perform it in front of millions of people knowing that immediately following, they are going to be critiqued. There’s not much on television that has real-life stakes as high as that.


10 responses

  1. I confess I jumped ship after Taylor Hicks won. Just could not take that. Every now and again I think I will join the bandwagon again, but it’s on SO OFTEN I just can’t get into it. Even with DVR!

    1. You may have noticed that I have erased Taylor Hicks from my Idol memory. Most recently he was appearing in Grease…

  2. I was a very (very) brief Idol fan… I just squirm in my seat in embarrassment for the ones who aren’t so good! I really can’t take it because I feel so bad for them! Haha!!

    Thanks for stopping by my blog!

    1. I think there was a conscious effort on the producers’ part this year to show fewer innocent but bad singers. Those who act the fool (to put it mildly) while knowing they are on camera deserve what they get and I don’t feel badly for them. Thanks for visiting and commenting!

  3. We didn’t have satelite/cable until three years ago. Before my daughter (20 months) was born, I watched the seasons from start to finish but now I just catch up whenever I can. I’m loving the new judges but I confess that I miss Simon ;).

    1. I got sick of the constant banter with Simon from everyone. Even some of the contestants somehow thought it was appropriate to backtalk Simon. THAT made me embarrassed for them, even more than the bad performances. Thanks for visiting and commenting!

  4. Guilty pleasure — yes! But I still can’t get over Pia’s being voted off the show . . .

    1. Did you see that she’s going to be on Dancing With the Stars as a guest singer?

  5. […] Why I Still Watch American Idol was a fun exercise in seeing who would comment. After watching the whole season, I think the Randy/Steven/Jennifer panel was very successful and I plan to watch it again in 2012. But I’m confused. I was watching all the X-Factor commercials (but not the actual show) and and couldn’t help notice the hugging at the end of the shows. Did Simon get nice on the new show? […]

  6. […] in for a treat this year. The competition among the remaining contestants is going to be fierce. I still love the dynamics of the judging team and we’ve already seen the star power that Idol is pulling in this year. Image […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: